irishbloke007 wrote:
the concept of being murdered in your dreams while at the same time being terrified of falling asleep to the point where you would go insane from sleep deprivation is way more scary than just being killed by some one in the woods
Paranormal Activity actually exploits similar fears to great effect. While it's not so much a matter of being murdered in your sleep, most of the truly terrifying stuff happens while the couple are asleep, and it does become quite clear that the lack of sleep is really wearing on them. This certainly adds to the confusion and terror they are experiencing, as they don't get much sleep as the film progresses. I'm not at all arguing that Nightmare on Elm Street is a fantastic film, I personally love it, and find it very scary for many of the reasons you cite.
irishbloke007 wrote:
the woods are fuckin scary but in elm street you knew some weird shit was gonna kill you
blair witch could have just been a nut in the woods and being that ive had paranormal experiences myself that would make people here shit themselves i can safely say id take a human in the woods trying to give me a poke with a knife over some freaky supernatural bugaboo
but thats my perspective i suppose people who havent seen ghosts and such would be more scared of something else
OK, now you lost me. I thought it was very clear throughout that it was NOT simply some person in the bush trying to scare them, but there was some terrible, malevolent force. I think that's what's so scary, imagining exactly what this witch truly is, and the extent of her power. Our three intrepid explorers clearly are losing their minds, whether that be from hunger, exhaustion or fear. The witch does such marvelously bizarre and creepy things, none of which really have any explanation (what's with the stick figures? Or leaving a little pouch of bloody pieces of Josh? We don't know, and it's better that way.) I reiterate then that the film is masterful exploration and examination of our deep-seated fear of the unknown, and wallows in a suffocating sense of dread and doom, as it looks more and more hopeless for our filmmaker friends.
Vindicated_Killer wrote:
I lived in a heavily wooded area all of my life and I was always unnerved by those half-cocked coyote packs. Goddamn pricks.
I don't know, coyotes never really bothered me, and I'm actually thrilled to hear them baying at night around here. A little nervous for the welfare of my cats, but otherwise I see coyotes as fairly harmless; smaller than most dogs and far less likely to approach you. Bears, on the other hand...
exploding_pool wrote:
Let me try to explain: I think Blair Witch is a great movie that really utilized an interesting technique to its advantage by making it a more immersed experience. So I'm not knocking the quality of the movie, in fact, I wish I could get the full effect of it. But I just have so many memories of stupid kids trying to scare each other back in my woods that it's like, "Okay, the idiots must have filmed it this time." Ironically, it feeling so personal is what keeps me from really getting the full impact of it.
Unfortunate, but totally understandable given how personal fear is. With that said, it does become apparent, as I mentioned earlier, that some powerful supernatural being is involved, and not merely stupid teens.
SPOILER ALERTIn terms of the ending of Paranormal Activity, I feel they definitely cheapened the ending by resorting to such a cheesy shock tactic at the end. The film had been deadly serious all throughout, and while Micah's body being hurled at the camera was certainly the loudest single reaction of the film, it was nowhere near the scariest. For a split second, half the theater shrieked, but they all quickly got over it, whereas the slightly less loud but far more prolonged screaming and moaning as Katie is dragged out of bed was far and a way the film's pinnacle in terms of crowd reaction. Maybe it's just me, but while I found the case study they found on the internet an interesting detail, the final reveal that she's possessed and somehow superhuman in strength and able to contort her face beyond human just ruined the final moments of the film for me. My favourite ending would be the one where she returns upstairs without Micah (I like the idea of not knowing for sure what happened to him), and remains catatonic for a day before the demon, in its final act of malice startles the police into killing her.